A Jackson-based developer plans to tear down the downtown Knit on Pearl block to build 39,500 square feet of short-term rentals and market-rate condos. 

The collection of buildings includes the beloved crafting shop Knit on Pearl, the state’s unemployment office, and a food pantry run by One22’s Jackson Cupboard.

The proposed homes would not be deed-restricted and no first-floor space would be reserved for commercial renters, said Cardinal Lands managing partner Albert Nichols.

“Commercial spaces are harder to get a tenant that is able to pay enough to cover the cost to build that space,” he said. 

Half a dozen tenants who spoke with KHOL said they had varying amounts of time left on leases, between a few months and a year and a half. Nichols said they will extend contracts as needed.

Since 2024, Cardinal Lands has also been working on two high-end communities in Driggs, Idaho. One is a development of 30 townhomes with residences starting at $1.65 million. Another, Hastings Lane, is a 240-acre residential development, according to the real estate outlet Thesis Driven. This is the firm’s first project in Jackson. Nearby newly built market-rate townhomes are priced around $6 million for a 3-bedroom. 

Businesses displaced 

For years, business owners at the corner of West Gill Avenue and North Glenwood Street worried that their rent could spike as the lot changed hands. 

This week, the plans were announced by a posted sign declaring a public meeting from 4 to 6 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 24 at the Teton County Library.

A woman cuts hair in a barber shop.
Hairstylist Melissa Wandurski, of tenant All About You Barber, called the redevelopment of 155 West Gill Avenue “disheartening” and “disappointing… “We don’t really have the money to go restart somewhere else,” she said. Credit: Evan Robinson-Johnson / KHOL

Hairstylist Melissa Wandurski plans to attend. She called the redevelopment “disheartening and disappointing.

“We don’t really have the money to go restart up somewhere else,” said Wandurski, of All About You Barber, one of the impacted tenants.

Chris Denny of the marketing firm Denny, ink. is considering moving his business to Salt Lake City. 

A man sits for an interview in his his rented office space.
Chris Denny of the marketing firm Denny, ink. is considering moving his business to Salt Lake City. “It’s a bigger issue than the building,” he said. “I’m challenged to afford to pay people enough to live here.” Credit: Evan Robinson-Johnson / KHOL

“It’s a bigger issue than the building,” he said. “I’m challenged to afford to pay people enough to live here.”

Knit on Pearl owner Margaret Brady said she would like to find a larger space that could allow her to stock more inventory for an online marketplace.

She is used to reassuring anxious customers about the daunting challenge of crafting a sweater or a scarf. Now Brady is doing the same, but for the future of her business, which will celebrate its 30-year anniversary in January. 

“It’s not the first space for the knit shop. We upgraded [about] 15 years ago, so maybe we can do it again,” she said. “But it’s sad to lose a building with character.”

An alternative space would likely lack the iconic green-and-white facade of the 700-square-foot converted cabin, which was moved onto its current foundation in the 1980s, Brady said. And she worries for her neighbors, too.

A woman surveys her shop's arrangement of yarn.
Knit on Pearl owner Margaret Brady is reassuring customers about the 30-year business’ future even as she struggles to find a suitable replacement space. Credit: Evan Robinson-Johnson / KHOL

The Wyoming Department of Workforce Services said it is searching for a replacement office. One22 operates food pantries throughout town and did not respond to requests for comment.

Locksmith Jim Woods, 73, said he’ll probably close up shop after 30 years at the building in downtown Jackson. “This whole place has gone to hell,” he said.

Not a ‘big building’ 

Designs for the new apartment complex are just under the town’s building size limit of 40,000 square feet. 

Anything larger — an added floor or greater density — would have forced developers to break up the project into multiple buildings.

“When you go over 40,000 square feet, you get treated completely differently,” developer Nichols said.

The project could still change based on community feedback, though he doesn’t expect to add commercial or deed-restricted units. 

“We could build a bigger building and incorporate those things, but the building gets a lot bigger and it’s more impactful and has a much bigger impact on the community,” Nichols said.

The proposal comes after plans for two hotels in the same neighborhood that are pushing out a longtime chiropractor, a hat shop and another barber. 

On the other side of Glenwood, the local Darwiche family is planning a boutique hotel. And further north, Utah-based Mogul Capital is planning a larger project.

A man talks to a customer in his locksmith shop.
Longtime locksmith Jim Woods, 73, said he’ll probably close up shop after 30 years at the building in downtown Jackson. “This whole place has gone to hell,” he said. Credit: Evan Robinson-Johnson / KHOL

Nichols previously told KHOL that the economics of preserving small businesses don’t make sense for their investors given the neighborhood changes. 

Most of those investors are based in Jackson, he said. 

Pressure on town leaders

Some tenants would like to see the Jackson Town Council do more to preserve affordable commercial space, especially close to Town Square.

“There’s not going to be anything left except the odd cowboy hat shop,” said Brady, of Knit on Pearl. 

Town councilors voted this week to ban first-floor residential development in a certain portion of downtown. The Cardinal Lands project will be affected if the rule takes effect before the project reaches a certain stage. The restriction seeks to combat the “high number of local businesses being displaced by the fast pace of downtown redevelopment.”

Jackson Mayor Arne Jorgensen said he had not immediately reviewed the specific plans from Cardinal Lands, but said the rule change will helps slow the loss of commercial space around downtown.

Brian Dunn, another Cardinal Lands managing partner, wrote to the council a day after the decision, arguing that commercial space is “not viable” for local businesses on the block at today’s construction prices.

“The result would be vacant storefronts in space that could have housed locals or visitors,” Dunn wrote.

Jorgensen previously told KHOL that it is more challenging to preserve affordable space for businesses than affordable housing.  

A sign gives notice of a community meeting outside a building.
A sign posted on the block advertises a community meeting from 4 to 6 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 24 at the Teton County Library. Some tenants said they wouldn’t be able to attend because of its proximity to Thanksgiving Day. Developer Nichols said he was also frustrated by the timing. Credit: Evan Robinson-Johnson / KHOL

“When you’re dealing with a privately owned business in a capitalist society, the tools just are not there,” Jorgensen said. “It’s a difficult task.”

Councilors will see the plans after the Nov. 24 public meeting. Nichols said input would help.

“With other projects we’ve worked on, we benefited a lot from speaking to neighbors and folks that immediately abut the site. They usually have an incredible depth of knowledge of the area,” he said.

Other mountain towns have struggled to keep local tenants in their business corridors. Aspen, Colorado, responded to the issue earlier this year by expanding an affordable housing land trust to include small businesses. 

This article has been updated to clarify the impact of the town’s new regulations and include additional comments from Cardinal Lands and Arne Jorgensen. — Ed.

Want More Stories Like This?

Donate any amount to support independent media in the Tetons.

Donate

Evan covers housing, politics and the workers of Jackson Hole. He was previously a business reporter for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and the health and education reporter for the Jackson Hole News&Guide....