Throughout what is, by some measures, the country’s most conservative state, Democratic leaders are saying that they feel part of something larger after this election season.
“We were, for the first time in my memory, a truly United States,” said Rep.-elect Britney Tennant, the only Democrat to flip a state House seat. Election night was a “real breakthrough” in pushing back against the “constant narrative that Dems are not welcome here,” she said.
Republicans swept all federal and statewide offices in Wyoming. They kept control of 90% of the Legislature, the most of any state besides West Virginia.
But election data show every Wyoming county shifted to the left by an average of about 21 points compared to the 2024 presidential race. That was enough to give Democratic candidates for U.S. Senate and House a third of the vote in their races.
The 16-point shift toward Democrats in the Senate race mirrored the national referendum on Trump, said Ryan Williamson, an associate professor of political science at the University of Wyoming.
“Wyomingites feel the same national strains as everyone else, from fuel and housing prices to war in the Middle East,” Williamson said.
Rep. Karlee Provenza, the minority House whip from Albany County, said the election results and her own tour of the state show Teton County is not the only blue dot in a red state.
“We have so much more in common than a party,” she said.
Provenza acknowledges Democrats could be thwarted by the Republican supermajority on issues like health care. Lawmakers have repeatedly rejected expanding Medicaid, for example, one of 10 states to do so.
And while Wyoming is not approaching something “radically different,” with a more moderate Republican makeup in the Capitol, Tennant is already looking for common ground.
The threatened closure of rural hospitals and dwindling access to primary care are “very much a bipartisan issue.”
“That reckoning is coming from both sides of the aisle at this point,” she said.

Others see the election night results as more of a mixed bag.
Former Rep. Jacob Wasserburger is the Republican who left the seat that Tennant won. He pointed out that Democrats got fewer votes in the gubernatorial race than the further-right Constitution Party, which gained major party status after Jackson activist Rebecca Bextel nearly 17% of the vote.
“It’s hard to say if Wyoming is becoming bluer,” Wasserburger said, though he added that many Trump supporters are unhappy. He said he wouldn’t be surprised if the country elects a Democratic president in 2028.
Others think there could be a shift back to the right if congressional Democrats focus on retribution rather than restoring the economy.
“If they don’t address [the economy] with some urgency, then this will be as emotional as a Saturday night college football game,” said Democratic U.S. Senate candidate James Byrd.
University of Wyoming polling found 49% of voters now disapprove of Trump in the state that gave him his largest margin of victory in 2024. The poll found 16% of voters approve of Congress, and 64% said the national economy has become worse over the past year.
It’s common for public sentiment to shift against the president’s party in midterm years, Williamson said.
“In 2010, during the backlash against President Obama’s first midterm, Wyoming Democrats went from seven state Senate seats to four. The forces are the same; only the president’s party changes,” he said.
The Wyoming Republican Party saw its own shift in the primary away from the further-right Freedom Caucus.
Provenza said she is also eager to keep incoming Republican governor, Eric Barlow, in check.
Republicans and Democrats are meeting in upcoming weeks to determine legislative priorities ahead of the January session.
Republicans meet in Gillette this weekend to hash those out.
Sen. Mike Gierau, a Jackson Democrat, said he wants to focus on housing, health care, child care and land use. Rep. Storer, a Jackson Democrat, said there is “a lot of interest” in holding nonpartisan primaries. State law changed in 2023 to prevent people from changing their party affiliation during the primary.
The Teton County delegation may have a helping hand in Rep. Andrew Byron, a Hoback Republican, who was recently nominated as House speaker pro tem, the second-in-command in the lower chamber.

